Holiday Sugar Cookies
On our tree-lined street in South Orange, there is a tradition between our neighbors. Today, after my husband dropped the hint a few months ago, our neighbors “up the hill” dropped off the best rum cake on the face of the earth. Soon, our neighbors “down the hill” will come bearing some sort of homemade heaven. And now, the pressure is on. The empty cookie boxes are calling, so we set out to bake our favorite holiday sugar cookies and mix up some royal icing. After a visit to the NY Cake store last weekend, I am now fully stocked with a rainbow of sanding sugars and a new cookie decorating kit by Kuhn Rikon. (For me, the cake decorating supply store on 22nd street is the equivalent to Barneys) Armed with five squeeze bottles with interchangeable decorator tips, this year was a breeze. Unlike pastry bags, these bottles are super easy for kids to handle. The most beautiful thing is that once the icing is made and the bottles are filled, they can last for up to a week at room temperature.
I have tried a bunch of sugar cookie recipes over the years but my favorite comes from The Joy of Cooking. The trick is to roll out the dough between sheets of wax paper then put them in the fridge- or the freezer if you are impatient. You can re-roll scraps and re-chill over and over and the dough never gets tough (I think this is because there is no extra dusting flour involved.)
Make ahead tip: Sometimes I make a double batch and roll out four or five sheets of dough, stack them on a cookie sheet, wrap them in cellophane, and freeze. When ready to bake, let them thaw on the counter a bit until they are a little pliable and you are set to go with the cookie cutters.
Rolled Sugar Cookie Recipe
2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
2/3 cups sugar
1 large egg
1/4 tsp. baking powder
1/8 tsp. salt
1 1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
2 1/3 cups flour
Beat the sugar and butter on medium until very fluffy. Add the egg, baking powder, salt, and vanilla and beat until well combined.
Stir in the flour little by little and beat gently until smooth.
Divide the dough into two balls and roll each between sheets of wax paper. Chill until firm.
Position a rack in the middle to upper third of the oven. Working with one sheet at a time, cut out cookies and place on a cookie sheet lined either with parchment paper or a SILPAT. (These are amazing)
Bake for 6-10 minutes at 350 degrees, depending on how cold the dough is. Keep a watch out to avoid browned edges.
Yield: 2-3 dozen cookies
A few notes: This recipe doubles really easily and then you have plenty to decorate, especially if you have kids involved. My son eats his cookies as fast as he decorates them. Also, it is worth buying a good quality organic butter because the cookies will taste much better.
Royal Icing
Royal Icing is great for holiday cookies because it dries hard and sanding sugars adhere to it like glitter on glue. I don’t remember where I learned this recipe, but I think it is pretty standard.
You will need:
Box of confectioner’s sugar (1 pound)
2 Tablespoons of Meringue Powder
4-6ish Tablespoons of warm water
Pour sugar and powder into mixer and mix on low for a few seconds. Add 3-4 Tablespoons of warm water and mix. Very gradually add more water until the consistency is not too thick and not too runny. It should make a ribbon when you spoon it rather than a peak. If it is too thick, your squeeze bottle will feel like a hand exerciser. (If you happen to add too much water then you can fix it by adding more powdered sugar.)
Divide the frosting into little bowls and add food coloring. Put it into bottles or pastry bags and it will keep at room temperature for up to a week.
For the kids, I made a double batch of cookies and a double batch of frosting-red, green, white, yellow, and blue. I put the sprinkles and sanding sugars in ramekins with little spoons and they had a great time. I set aside about half of the cookies for myself for later.
After the kids were all snug in their beds, I sat down with some spiked egg nog, lit my “Home for the Holidays” Yankee Candle, and turned on my Charlie Brown Christmas album. Zen and the art of making holiday cookies…
Holiday Sugar Cookies


























































































Christine 9:50 pm on November 28, 2011 Permalink
You both did such a beautiful job !! I loved the martinis, all of the amazing food and of course the company !! It was a Thanksgiving Blast !! Thank you for a wonderful day.
The pictures on this blog are gorgeous !